top of page

Recipe - Pistachio Olive Oil Cake

  • Writer: Pietro & Prima Materia
    Pietro & Prima Materia
  • May 24, 2019
  • 2 min read

Updated: Jul 17, 2019



Cake recipe

This recipe has gone through many iterations (as have I) since I started working it in 2007. It was originally based on recipes from Pierre Hermé and David Everitt-Matthias. It spent some time on and off menus when I was in kitchens and is to date probably my most requested recipe. I like taking the Sicilian approach and pairing with Prickly Pear sorbet, bitter components or something bright and tart to counteract the rich, alkaline nature of the cake. This ratio of butter to olive oil yields a fairly round richness, but you can raise the the EVOO percentage and use a peppery Tuscan or Nuovo oil to yield a much more phenolic and spicy cake. You can have some bitterness at work here too depending on the oil which adds a complex nuance that is really fun to work with. Don't fear bitter - playing with it highly is recommended. You can even take this cake to a salty savory space that could even counterpoint charcuterie. You can even pair nearly dry wines or bubbles all the way to Vin Santo successfully.

Recipe:

3 oz. coarse grain rice flour

8 oz. unsalted shelled pistachios – skins removed as much as possible. I like to use about half-and-half untoasted bright green for color and half toasted for flavor 3 oz. all purpose or pastry flour (preferred) 1 tsp. baking powder a good pinch salt ----- 6 oz. extra virgin olive oil 4 oz. barely melted butter ----- 4 whole eggs 9 oz. sugar zest of 1 lemon and 1 orange, plus juice of one half lemon 9” springform pan, placed on baking sheet Bake at 300F for approximately 70 minutes. Cake will remain soft and a toothpick may not come out completely clean, but it will firmly set. 200F is a good internal temperature target. Use the jiggle test. Do not remove from pan until the cake is completely cool, at least 2 hours. Method: Combine rice flour, pistachios, flour, baking powder, and salt in food processor and process until a medium-fine textured crumb appears but still has a little chunky texture. Make sure it isn't overly uniform as this is "rustic" cake. Mix barely melted unbroken butter with olive oil. In a mixer whip eggs at medium speed while adding sugar. We don't want to over-inflate them whipping to ribbon stage but the sugar should dissolve with minimal foam. Slowly add the butter/olive oil mixture. Mix well but creating an emulsion is not necessary. Add juice, zest, and then gently fold in pistachio mixture from food processor. Pour into well buttered springform pan and bake as indicated above. For an easy accompaniment gently simmer sliced peaches or pears with one half bottle of red wine, 2 tablespoons of sugar, 2 cloves and 1 star anise until syrup consistency. Remove star anise and cloves, spoon cooled fruit mixture and syrup onto plate with a bit of whipped cream.


www.prima-materia.com

2 Comments


rita nielsen
rita nielsen
Aug 19, 2023

Hi There, I made this and am wondering if there may be a mis print with the flour portions. I followed instructions. After the cake cooled there was a lot of uncooked batter. I baked for another 30 minutes and still found the cake to be very wet and oily. Should I store the cake in the fridge? I used extra large eggs? I have comared this recipe to other similar and the flour portions are double.


Thank-you,


Rita

Like
Pietro & Prima Materia
Pietro & Prima Materia
Aug 20, 2023
Replying to

Hi Rita,

Sorry that the cake didn't turn out. I just made it again about 2 months ago for a wine event using this very recipe. My thought is that maybe the pistachio wasn't ground finely enough? When all the dry ingredients are blitzed up in the food processor the pistachios should look like pretty fine almond meal plus about 25% little green chunks of pistachio so that most of the pistachio is actually acting as a binder.


My other thought is that maybe the eggs were extraordinarily large?


If the cake hasn't cooked through (usually 60-75 minutes for a 10" springform at 300F - or when the temp hits 200 inside, it will swell and then fall as it…


Like
bottom of page